Skip to content

Fatal accident claims Scotland

Quick Answer

When someone dies because of another person's negligence, close relatives can claim in Scotland under the Damages (Scotland) Act 2011 for loss of society, lost financial support, lost services and funeral costs, and the estate may continue the deceased's own claim. Court proceedings generally have to be raised within three years of the death, with some exceptions. Claims a firm accepts are usually funded by a success fee agreement.

Losing a family member because of someone else's negligence is devastating. On top of grief, many families face financial uncertainty and unanswered questions about what happened. A fatal accident claim in Scotland cannot undo what has occurred, but it can provide financial security and a degree of accountability.

This guide explains who can claim, what compensation is available under Scots law, and how the process works.


Who can bring a fatal accident claim in Scotland?

Fatal accident claims in Scotland are governed by the Damages (Scotland) Act 2011. The Act specifies who has the right to claim and what they can recover.

Relatives with an automatic right to claim

The following relatives have an automatic right to claim where their relationship with the deceased is established:

  • Spouse or civil partner
  • A person who had been living with the deceased as husband, wife or civil partner for at least two years immediately before the death
  • A parent
  • A child (including step-children and children accepted into the family)
  • A brother or sister
  • A grandparent
  • A grandchild
  • An uncle or aunt
  • A nephew or niece
  • A cousin

The court can also allow a claim by other relatives in appropriate circumstances.


What can relatives claim for in a Scottish fatal accident case?

Loss of society

Loss of society compensates relatives for the loss of the personal relationship with the deceased, including the love, care, guidance and affection they provided. This is a distinctly Scottish provision and has no direct equivalent in English law.

Loss of society awards are assessed by the court for each relative, reflecting the closeness of the relationship and the circumstances. England and Wales instead have a single fixed bereavement award available to a narrower group of relatives, so the two systems are not directly comparable.

Loss of financial support (dependency)

Where the deceased was providing financial support to family members, dependants can claim for the loss of that support. This is calculated based on the deceased's likely future earnings and the extent to which those earnings were being used to support the pursuer.

For a spouse or cohabiting partner with children, this can be a substantial sum, particularly where the deceased was a high earner or young at the time of death.

Services

Where the deceased provided services to the family that now have to be obtained or paid for (for example, childcare, home maintenance, gardening), the family can claim for the reasonable cost of replacing those services.

Reasonable funeral expenses

The cost of the deceased's funeral is recoverable as a head of claim.

The deceased's own claim (solatium and patrimonial loss)

The deceased's estate can also claim for the pain, suffering and financial losses the deceased experienced between the date of the accident and the date of death. This forms part of the estate's claim and passes to the estate.


How is loss of society calculated in Scotland?

There is no fixed figure. Each relative's award is assessed separately, guided by awards made in earlier cases, and juries in the Court of Session have sometimes awarded more than judges. Factors include:

FactorWhy it matters
The relationshipSpouses, partners, parents and children are usually at the higher end; other relatives receive awards that reflect their closeness.
How close the family actually wasEvidence of the day-to-day relationship matters, not only the family tie.
AgesThe age of the person who died and of each relative affects what has been lost.
Circumstances of the deathThe distress caused to relatives can be relevant.

We do not publish figures because previous awards vary widely and depend on facts a web page cannot see.

What causes fatal accident claims in Scotland?

Fatal accident claims can arise wherever negligence causes a death. Common causes include:

  • Fatal road traffic accidents (car, motorcycle, cyclist, pedestrian, HGV)
  • Fatal accidents at work, including falls from height, machinery accidents, and exposure to hazardous substances
  • Medical negligence resulting in death
  • Deaths from asbestos-related diseases (mesothelioma)
  • Fatal accidents in public places due to inadequate safety measures

What is a Fatal Accident Inquiry (FAI) in Scotland?

A Fatal Accident Inquiry (FAI) is a public judicial inquiry held in Scotland to investigate the circumstances of a death. FAIs are distinct from civil compensation claims. An FAI is held in the Sheriff Court and is presided over by a sheriff.

FAIs are mandatory in certain circumstances (deaths in workplace accidents, custody, and some other situations) and discretionary in others. The outcome of an FAI is a determination by the sheriff setting out the facts of the death, any systemic failures, and recommendations.

An FAI is not a compensation claim. It does not award damages. However, the findings of an FAI can be highly relevant evidence in a subsequent civil compensation claim, and your solicitor will monitor any FAI proceedings closely.

An FAI can also be a source of important evidence about the circumstances of a death where liability is disputed in a compensation claim.


Records that help a fatal accident claim

There is no need to gather anything before you ask for advice, but these are often needed later:

  • The death certificate and, where relevant, any post-mortem report or Procurator Fiscal correspondence.
  • Any police, Health and Safety Executive or Fatal Accident Inquiry documents.
  • Evidence of the person's income and what it was spent on, such as payslips, tax returns and household bills.
  • Funeral invoices and other costs since the death.
  • A short note of the family members who were close to the person and how.

What is the time limit for a fatal accident claim in Scotland?

Under the Prescription and Limitation (Scotland) Act 1973, relatives generally have three years from the date of death to raise court proceedings.

Where the cause of death was not immediately apparent (for example, a death from an asbestos-related disease), the three-year period may run from the date the family first knew or could reasonably have known that the death was caused by negligence. Other rules can affect the deceased person's own claim and claims with a cross-border element, so do not rely on a single date. Sending an enquiry through this site does not stop the clock, so take advice early if a deadline may be close.


Is a fatal accident claim handled on no win no fee?

Thompsons Scotland LLP, which receives enquiries from this site, handles fatal accident claims and offers no win no fee terms on claims it accepts. Under a success fee agreement there is nothing to pay upfront and no legal fee if the claim fails. If it succeeds, a success fee is deducted from your damages. Scottish regulations cap it at 20% of the first £100,000, 10% of the next £400,000 and 2.5% above £500,000, including VAT; these are ceilings, and the firm may charge less.

Each relative's award, and the deceased's estate claim, may be treated differently in the agreement, so ask how the fee applies to each. What the fee is taken from, whether any insurance premium is deducted, who pays the outlays and what happens if you stop part-way all depend on the agreement. The receiving firm states that it takes its fee from the injury element (solatium) only; ask for every term in writing before you sign. Use the funding questions checklist.


How does a fatal accident claim work in Scotland?

Step 1: Free assessment

A solicitor meets with the family to understand the circumstances of the death and advise on the prospect of a claim. This is done sensitively and at whatever pace suits the family.

Step 2: Evidence gathering

Your solicitor will gather evidence including accident reports, police reports, medical records, witness statements, and, where relevant, the findings of any Fatal Accident Inquiry.

Step 3: Pre-Action Protocol

A formal letter of claim is sent to the responsible party. The defender has three months to investigate and respond.

Step 4: Valuing the claim

An independent forensic accountant or actuary may be instructed to calculate the financial dependency and future losses. Medical experts may report on the circumstances and cause of death.

Step 5: Settlement or court proceedings

Most fatal accident claims settle through negotiation. If the case cannot be resolved, proceedings are raised in the Sheriff Court or Court of Session. Court proceedings are a last resort.


Frequently asked questions

Can we claim even if there has been a Fatal Accident Inquiry? Yes. An FAI is a separate process from a civil compensation claim. Its findings can support your claim, but you are not prevented from claiming regardless of the FAI outcome.

What if a criminal prosecution is taking place as well? A criminal prosecution (for example, for death by dangerous driving) and a civil compensation claim are entirely separate. You can pursue a civil claim regardless of whether criminal proceedings are underway or have concluded. A criminal conviction is strong evidence of negligence in a civil claim.

Can we claim if our family member was partly at fault? Yes. Contributory negligence applies in Scotland: the compensation is reduced in proportion to the deceased's share of the blame, but the family is not prevented from claiming.

What if the accident happened at work and the employer no longer exists? Employers were required to hold employers' liability insurance. Even if the employer has ceased trading, the insurer remains liable. Tracing the insurer is part of your solicitor's role.

What if multiple family members want to claim? Each eligible family member has their own right to claim. Your solicitor will coordinate the claims and ensure all eligible relatives are represented.

Does the fatal accident claim affect benefits entitlement? It can. If the family receives means-tested benefits, a large compensation payment may affect entitlement. A personal injury trust can protect the award. Your solicitor can advise on this.

How long will the claim take? Fatal accident claims vary considerably. A case where liability is admitted and the family's financial dependency is clear can settle more quickly; disputed liability or complex dependency takes longer.


Ask for a free assessment

We understand that pursuing a claim is the last thing on your mind when you are grieving. A solicitor will handle every aspect of the process on your behalf, with care and discretion, so that you can focus on your family.

Call 0141 566 8059 for a free, no-obligation assessment. Your enquiry goes to Thompsons Scotland LLP, a firm regulated by the Law Society of Scotland, who will tell you whether they can take on your fatal accident claim on a No Win No Fee basis.

request a free assessment online.

Related Guides

Find out if you have a claim

A short conversation costs nothing and commits you to nothing. Your details go to Thompsons Scotland LLP, solicitors regulated by the Law Society of Scotland.

Last updated by the Personal Injury Claims Scotland editorial team. This is an editorial update, not a review by a solicitor, and the page is general information rather than legal advice.